Prison for man convicted of gross negligence manslaughter over farm death
A man has been convicted of gross negligence manslaughter at Exeter Crown Court in relation to the death of 20-year-old Lauren Scott.
Neil Carpenter ran Springfield Farm, a 10-acre small holding just outside Dawlish, where Lauren died on 4 March 2017.
Lauren’s death was caused by a catastrophic entanglement with a Power Take Off (PTO) shaft running from a tractor to an old milling machine used for preparing animal feed. Lauren was operating the machine when her hair and clothes got caught in the PTO shaft. She died instantly.
PTOs are used to power farm machinery. A tractor’s engine drives a rotating shaft which connects to the unit to be powered. The power and speed of rotation make PTOs incredibly dangerous, as there is no possibility of someone pulling away if they come into contact. It is, therefore, a fundamental rule of farm safety that PTOs are fitted with adequate covers. In this case the PTO cover was poorly maintained and did not fully fit. Parts of the shaft were exposed and the cover was broken so that it caught on the shaft and span with it.
The Police and Health and Safety Executive carried out a joint investigation. An HSE inspector issued Prohibition Notices on 11 pieces of equipment at the farm, meaning that they must not be used until they had been improved to an acceptable safety standard.
Neil Carpenter was found guilty following the trial at Exeter Crown Court and was sentenced today to 4 years and 6 months in prison.
Carpenter had also pleaded guilty to 2 other offences under the Health and Safety Act and was sentenced to 8 months in prison for in relation to machinery guarding and 2 months in prison for failing to provide workers with helmets when they operated the farm all-terrain vehicle (ATV). All sentences are to run concurrently.
HSE Inspector Simon Jones said:
'At the centre of this trial was the grossly inadequate guarding of a Power Take Off (PTO) shaft'. It is now over 60 years since the law was introduced requiring guarding on PTOs. The guarding standards on a PTO are easily understood and haven’t changed in all of those 60 years. It is inconceivable that a farmer such as Neil Carpenter would not know what those standards were and what the horrific consequences would have been if anyone became entangled on a PTO on his farm’
‘The guarding on this PTO was utterly appalling. Had it been properly guarded then Lauren Scott would not have been able to become entangled; such a guard would have cost as little as £75’
The general safety standards seen on Neil Carpenter’s farm as part of this investigation show that he had a negligent attitude towards safety on his farm, an attitude that has ultimately led to the death of Lauren Scott.
Devon and Cornwall Police Senior Investigating Officer – Detective Inspector Steve Davies said:
Neil Carpenter ran his farm with a complete disrespect for safety and which ultimately cost the life of Lauren Scott. His basic approach to health and safety showed a flagrant disregard for regulations that are there to protect individuals working at farms from injury and death.
During the investigation and trial he has distanced himself from any responsibility for Laurens death and from the outset gave information that was inconsistent and eventually proved to be lies. His defence was that he had not been near the mill that day and that Lauren used it without his knowledge. The Police suspected that he had been using the mill and had asked Lauren to help him. My team carried out a detailed and thorough investigation with the key evidence being a video found on Lauren’s phone.
The video was taken by Lauren whilst she was feeding pigs on the farm less than 30 minutes before the tragedy occurred. This video was examined by image and sound experts. By unbelievable chance about 2 seconds of Laurens video caught the tractor in the distant background. The expert work concluded that not only was there someone in that tractor but also sound of the engine starting up. With only Lauren and Carpenter at the farm the only logical explanation with Lauren making the video was that this person had to be Carpenter and that he had lied about using the mill. Though he accepted it could be him he never gave an explanation stating to the jury he could not remember. In the end the jury have accepted that Mr Carpenter was grossly negligent for Laurens death.
Ann Hampshire from the Crown Prosecution Service said:
“Lauren was a volunteer at the farm. She wasn’t paid, but took pleasure from the animals and enjoyed helping out. Neil Carpenter had a duty of care to ensure that the environment and equipment to which she had access was safe. His failings in this respect were serious enough that they amounted to a crime.
“The Prosecution argued that Mr Carpenter was not telling the truth about how often the mill was used, its working order and the series of events on the day.